Even If AI Data Center Revenue Drops to Zero: Bernstein Says Oracle (ORCL.US) Stock Is Undervalued, Keeps $325 Price Target

Stock News
11/18

Despite ongoing market concerns about the debt burden, customer performance risks, and capital expenditure pressures stemming from Oracle (ORCL.US)'s heavy investment in artificial intelligence (AI) data centers, Bernstein believes that Oracle's current stock price is already below its theoretical valuation when completely excluding its AI data center business.

In a research report published on November 18, Bernstein pointed out that even assuming all of Oracle's AI data center customers stop honoring their contracts, the related business revenue drops completely to zero, the approximately $40 billion in hardware assets already purchased cannot be monetized, and the company still has to bear existing debt and interest expenses, its core business would still be worth $133 per share.

Compared to Oracle's closing price of $115 on November 17, this extreme bearish scenario valuation is still about 16% higher. Bernstein therefore reiterated its "Outperform" rating on Oracle and maintained its $325 price target, implying approximately 183% potential upside.

AI Business Earning Nothing — Oracle Still Worth $133?

Bernstein noted that Oracle has become one of the most controversial stocks in the technology sector. Investor concerns mainly focus on four areas: the economic returns of AI data center investments, massive capital expenditures and financing needs, the company's execution capability, and the long-term sustainability of its existing business.

In particular, Oracle's large-scale AI computing contracts with technology companies such as OpenAI, while providing support for future revenue growth, have also raised market doubts about whether customers can continue to fulfill their obligations.

To assess the potential downside risks facing Oracle, Bernstein constructed an extreme bearish valuation scenario. In this model, AI data center customers including OpenAI, Meta (META.US), Nvidia (NVDA.US), and AMD (AMD.US) all stop honoring their contracts; even though the relevant contracts are non-cancelable in principle, it is assumed that Oracle cannot obtain default compensation.

The approximately $40 billion in server, networking equipment, and power and cooling system hardware assets that Oracle has already purchased are considered worthless — they can neither continue to be used nor be sold for cash. More conservatively, Bernstein assumes that Oracle still has to bear the debt and related interest expenses previously raised for building AI data centers, and incorporates share dilution from equity financing into the valuation.

In other words, this scenario not only completely removes the future revenue and profits of the AI data center business, but also retains the financial burden already generated by the related investments. Even so, Bernstein calculates that Oracle's core business still has a fair valuation of $133 per share.

This valuation is lower than the $137 per share estimated by the firm in February 2026, mainly because Oracle has since increased debt, purchased more hardware, and expanded the scale of its AI data center business. However, Bernstein emphasized that this model does not include an "AI winter" scenario of a comprehensive collapse in global generative AI demand, but rather assumes that Oracle's existing AI customers default while other cloud computing and software businesses continue to develop normally.

Traditional Business Still Has Growth Potential — Fiscal 2030 Revenue Could Approach $100 Billion

Bernstein believes that the market is overly focused on the risks of Oracle's AI data center investments while overlooking the long-term value of its traditional software and cloud computing businesses.

The firm pointed out that Oracle's database business has high customer stickiness and profit margins, and its software services such as enterprise resource planning (ERP) and human capital management (HCM) also have strong business stability. At the same time, Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI)'s traditional computing business that does not rely on generative AI, as well as sovereign cloud, private cloud, and multi-cloud services, are still expected to benefit from the ongoing trend of enterprises migrating to the cloud.

According to Bernstein's estimates, even after completely excluding AI data center revenue, Oracle's core business revenue is still expected to grow from approximately $61 billion in fiscal 2026 to $98 billion in fiscal 2030. Among this, core business revenue is projected at approximately $67 billion in fiscal 2027, increasing to $75 billion in fiscal 2028 and further reaching $85 billion in fiscal 2029.

As revenue grows and operating leverage gradually materializes, Oracle's non-AI business operating margin is expected to rise from 35% in fiscal 2026 to 39% in fiscal 2030. While continuing to account for AI data center financing interest costs, Bernstein expects Oracle's core business net income in fiscal 2030 to still reach $27.1 billion, with earnings per share of approximately $10.8.

In terms of valuation methodology, Bernstein referenced the valuation levels of software companies including Microsoft (MSFT.US), SAP (SAP.US), Salesforce (CRM.US), and ServiceNow (NOW.US). These companies have an average forward price-to-earnings ratio of approximately 24.4 times.

Bernstein assumed that Oracle's core business earnings per share will compound at approximately 20% over the next two years, and applied a fair price-to-earnings ratio of 25 times, corresponding to a valuation of approximately $133 per share. Bernstein believes that given the competitive advantages of Oracle's database business and the high stickiness of enterprise software customers, its core business could theoretically even command a valuation premium, but the firm did not include this factor in its model out of prudence.

$288 Billion Data Center Lease Becomes Market Focus — Bernstein Says Risks Are Exaggerated

Beyond the fulfillment capability of AI customers, the massive data center lease contracts signed by Oracle are also a major source of market concern.

Bernstein pointed out that Oracle previously signed data center lease agreements with a total value of approximately $288 billion, with lease terms of 15 to 19 years. These lease commitments are closely related to the approximately $317 billion in non-cancelable contract amounts the company obtained from customers such as OpenAI.

Investors worry that once major customers like OpenAI fail to fulfill their computing power procurement commitments, Oracle may be forced to bear long-term rent on idle data centers, putting sustained pressure on free cash flow. However, Bernstein believes that this concern overlooks the reuse value of data center assets.

First, Oracle's data center capacity will not all be put into use at once, but will be delivered gradually over the coming years. Therefore, even if some customers fail to fulfill their obligations, the company still has time to find other customers or adjust usage. Second, the $288 billion in lease commitments are spread over contract periods of 15 to 19 years, which does not mean Oracle needs to pay the full amount in the short term.

Bernstein estimates that the peak annual expenditure for the related leases is approximately $15 billion to $19 billion, and this level is not expected to be reached until around fiscal 2030. In addition, the firm believes that as long as the generative AI industry does not experience a comprehensive collapse, the market will maintain high demand for data centers with sufficient power supply.

Even if original customers exit, Oracle could potentially sublease data centers or use the related facilities for traditional cloud computing business, reducing losses from idle assets. Bernstein estimates that the potential annual market size for global Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) and Platform as a Service (PaaS) is approximately $1.2 trillion to $1.4 trillion, while the actual market size is currently less than half of this potential.

Therefore, the data center demand brought by enterprises' ongoing migration to the cloud is expected to provide additional utilization space for Oracle's existing assets.

$40 Billion in Hardware Assets May Not Be Sunk Costs

Regarding investors' concerns about GPU and server procurement risks, Bernstein also believes that Oracle has greater flexibility than the market expects.

The firm estimates that for every $1 of annual AI revenue Oracle generates, it needs to invest approximately $2.5 to $3 in computing assets, with the expected useful life of the related assets being approximately 6 years. However, Oracle typically purchases related hardware only about 3 to 6 months before a data center becomes operational, rather than completing all purchases years in advance.

This means that even if AI customers suddenly stop honoring their contracts, Oracle may not have already borne the full hardware procurement costs for future years. Bernstein estimates that Oracle currently has approximately $40 billion in hardware assets in the construction or procurement process, including not only GPU servers but also storage, networking, memory, and power and cooling equipment.

Some of these assets can be redirected to traditional cloud computing workloads or have their value recovered through sales or leasing. Notably, in the aforementioned $133 per share bearish valuation model, Bernstein did not include any recovery gains these hardware assets might generate. The firm believes this further demonstrates the conservatism of its valuation assumptions.

AI Investment Returns Expected to Materialize Gradually — Fiscal 2030 Free Cash Flow Could Reach $80 Billion

Under normal operating scenarios, Bernstein remains optimistic about Oracle's growth prospects over the coming years. The firm expects that as AI data center contracts gradually convert into actual revenue, Oracle's total revenue in fiscal 2030 could reach approximately $234 billion, higher than the company's previously stated target of $225 billion.

Among this, AI cloud infrastructure business revenue is expected to reach approximately $136 billion, becoming an important driver of the company's overall growth. However, the AI data center business has relatively lower gross margins, and as its revenue share increases, Oracle's overall gross margin may decline from approximately 66% in fiscal 2026 to 47% in fiscal 2030.

Nevertheless, Bernstein expects that as data centers gradually become operational and capital expenditure growth slows, Oracle's free cash flow position will improve significantly. According to financing and cash flow plans previously disclosed by management, after completing approximately $20 billion in new financing, the company is expected to need no further fundraising and is expected to achieve positive free cash flow in the second half of fiscal 2028.

Bernstein expects Oracle's free cash flow to reach approximately $30 billion in fiscal 2029 and further increase to approximately $80 billion in fiscal 2030. Looking further ahead, the firm's model shows that Oracle's revenue in fiscal 2035 could approach $396 billion, with operating profit of approximately $160 billion and free cash flow potentially reaching $233 billion.

However, these long-term projections are highly dependent on continued growth in AI data center demand, existing customers fulfilling their obligations, and the company smoothly executing its expansion plans — they are not guaranteed operating outcomes.

Stock Price Has Fallen Sharply from Yearly High — Bernstein Bullish on Risk-Reward Ratio

As of the close on November 17, Oracle's stock price was $115, down approximately 47.7% over the past 12 months and about 41% year-to-date. Bernstein believes that Oracle's current stock price not only fails to fully reflect the value that the AI data center business may create in the future, but is even below its core business valuation under extreme bearish assumptions.

The firm pointed out that the market may be giving Oracle's traditional software business too low a valuation, or may have already priced in some risk of an AI industry demand collapse. However, Bernstein believes that Oracle's core database and enterprise software businesses still have strong competitiveness, and once AI data center investments begin generating the expected cash flows, they will bring significant additional value to the company.

The firm expects that as more data centers become operational in the coming quarters, customer contract execution is verified, and investor confidence in OpenAI's long-term business prospects improves, Oracle's stock price is expected to gradually recover. Bernstein stated that a shift in market sentiment could take 18 months, or it could happen sooner.

Based on the support provided by core business valuation and the potential long-term growth opportunities of the AI data center business, Bernstein reiterated its "Outperform" rating on Oracle and maintained its $325 price target.

免责声明:投资有风险,本文并非投资建议,以上内容不应被视为任何金融产品的购买或出售要约、建议或邀请,作者或其他用户的任何相关讨论、评论或帖子也不应被视为此类内容。本文仅供一般参考,不考虑您的个人投资目标、财务状况或需求。TTM对信息的准确性和完整性不承担任何责任或保证,投资者应自行研究并在投资前寻求专业建议。

热议股票

  1. 1
     
     
     
     
  2. 2
     
     
     
     
  3. 3
     
     
     
     
  4. 4
     
     
     
     
  5. 5
     
     
     
     
  6. 6
     
     
     
     
  7. 7
     
     
     
     
  8. 8
     
     
     
     
  9. 9
     
     
     
     
  10. 10