American Eagle shares were briefly jolted higher as Wall Street reacted positively to a top- and bottom-line beat but faded the knee-jerk gains on the retailer’s underwhelming outlook for the full year, tariff-related margin pressure, and 10% increase in inventory at the end of the year.

For the fourth quarter, an 8% increase in comparable store sales soundly beat 1.3% estimates, led by a 23% surge in traffic at its Aerie banner (versus +6% in 2024). This helped generate a 10% increase in sales to $1.76B, beating expectations by $20M, and contributed to an adjusted profit of $0.84 per share, up 30 cents from a year ago and 13 cents above estimates.

Gross margin, however, was compressed by 30 basis points to 37% due to a net tariff impact of 280 basis points, and as increased markdowns were largely offset by leverage on positive sales combined with lower costs, favorable currency exchange rates, and operational efficiencies.

For the current quarter, American Eagle Outfitters expects comparable sales to increase by high single digits, gross margin to be up from a year earlier, and operating income of $20M to $25M versus the $15M estimate from two analysts.

For FY26, comparable sales are seen increasing mid-single digits and operating income of $390M to $410M. Additionally, the company expects to spend between $250M and $260M on capital expenditures, almost half of what was anticipated.

“We enter 2026 from a position of strength with the goal of building on this year’s successes. The first quarter is off to a positive start, and we remain focused on investing in our brands and driving additional corporate savings and efficiency across the business. I’m confident that our strategic actions will lead to long-term profitable growth and shareholder value creation,” he concluded.