MSCI Removing Strategy From Its Indexes Could Undermine Its Bitcoin Purchasing Model

Deep News
11/12

Analysts say MSCI's decision to remove Strategy from its equity indexes could weaken the company's ability to keep buying Bitcoin.

The index provider MSCI has confirmed that it will remove Strategy, the world's largest publicly listed Bitcoin holder, from its widely tracked global equity indexes, including the MSCI USA Index, after the close of trading on November 30. MSCI made the decision under new screening rules for "non-operating" companies adopted on October 15. Those rules also led to the removal of Tokyo-listed Bitcoin treasury company Metaplanet from the MSCI Japan Small Cap Index.

Analysts said the move could weaken Strategy's ability to keep buying Bitcoin, although the impact may already be largely priced in. MSCI indexes are made up of baskets of stocks, and many funds must allocate assets in line with index constituents. When a stock is removed, funds tracking the index need to sell their holdings, creating selling pressure. However, being removed from an index does not mean the stock is delisted from an exchange, nor does it force Strategy to sell the Bitcoin it holds. As of press time, Strategy held 850,364 Bitcoins worth about $62.6 billion.

Passive fund selling pressure

Estimates vary on how much selling pressure Strategy shares (MSTR) may face in the coming days. Institutions including BloFin Research expect the related selling to total about 13 million shares. In a post on a social platform, BloFin Research said: "Funds tracking MSCI indexes are expected to need to sell about 13 million shares, equivalent to about 3.1% of Strategy's issued shares, below the stock's typical one-day volume." That estimate is consistent with Strategy's own analysis. In its response to MSCI's consultation paper, Strategy said funds tracking MSCI's global investable market indexes together hold about 13 million shares of the company, equal to about 3.1% of its total basic issued shares. That is less than one day's trading volume for Strategy and, based on Wednesday's share price, worth about $1.6 billion. However, JPMorgan estimated in November 2025 that removing Strategy from MSCI indexes could trigger outflows of about $2.8 billion. If other index providers follow suit, total outflows could rise to $8.8 billion. But the bank's forecast was based on MSCI's original proposal, not the rules ultimately adopted in this review.

Impact on future Bitcoin purchases

Analysts believe this passive selling, and the resulting decline in passive index investment demand, could affect how Strategy finances new Bitcoin purchases. BloFin Research explained: "The bigger risk lies in Strategy's Bitcoin accumulation model. Strategy relies heavily on capital markets financing to buy Bitcoin. Losing passive index investment demand could further compress its modified net asset value (mNAV) premium, which is already close to 1.08 times. A narrower premium would reduce the accretive effect of new share issuance, potentially slowing future Bitcoin accumulation."

To understand this, it helps to first understand the mNAV metric. mNAV measures the market's valuation of a company relative to the value of the Bitcoin assets it holds. When mNAV is above 1, it means investors are willing to pay more for the company's stock than the value of the Bitcoin it holds; when mNAV is below 1, it means the opposite. Strategy has long funded Bitcoin purchases by issuing convertible bonds, preferred stock, and selling common stock through at-the-market (ATM) offerings. This strategy depends on the company's stock trading at a premium to the Bitcoin assets it holds, meaning an mNAV above 1. Because each newly issued share is sold for more than the value of the Bitcoin assets behind it, this financing method can be accretive, increasing the amount of Bitcoin represented by each share held by existing investors. When mNAV is close to 1, issuing new shares creates almost no additional value; when mNAV is below 1, issuing more shares is dilutive. As a result, reduced passive investment demand could further compress this valuation premium, weakening Strategy's Bitcoin purchasing model.

The mNAV premium has already narrowed sharply

Strategy's mNAV has fallen from a peak of 3.4 times in November 2024 to about 1.08 times as of press time. The company's recent use of capital already reflects this change. According to a filing submitted by Strategy on November 9, in the week ended November 8, the company raised $283.8 million by selling 2.05 million common shares, but only $81.9 million of that was used to buy Bitcoin, acquiring 1,036 coins. Most of the proceeds, $188.3 million, were used to repurchase STRC preferred stock, while another $13.6 million was added to cash reserves. The same filing showed that as of November 8, Strategy held $4.77 billion in cash reserves. During that week, the company withdrew $21.1 million from cash reserves to pay preferred stock dividends and reported that it sold no Bitcoin. So in a sense, the worst case may already be reflected in the share price. Markus Thielen, founder of 10x Research, holds this view. Thielen said: "With the net asset value premium approaching 1 times, the stock's leverage to Bitcoin has weakened, and we expect it to continue underperforming Bitcoin." He said: "We do not expect this event to have spillover effects on Bitcoin itself. Since Bitcoin's price peaked a year ago, Bitcoin treasury companies have had less and less influence on the market. As their net asset value premiums keep narrowing, many investors realize that these companies create no additional value beyond the Bitcoin they hold." He explained that some funds tracking benchmark indexes will have to sell MSTR shares, but those shares should find buyers at slightly lower prices. Thielen said: "This outcome has long been widely expected by the market, so most of the impact is already reflected in the price. Historically, the impact of such announcements is usually priced in long before the event actually happens, and this event will occur next month." He added that many funds had already been underweight Strategy, meaning their actual holdings were below the index-prescribed weight, so actual selling pressure may be smaller than the headline numbers suggest.

Independent Bitcoin analyst Derin Olenik is less optimistic. Although his estimate of potential MSTR selling pressure matches JPMorgan's, he believes the bigger cost is the blow the event will deal to the market narrative of institutional investor adoption of Bitcoin, on which the entire Bitcoin treasury company model increasingly depends. Olenik said: "Confirmation of index removal could bring at least $2.8 billion in selling pressure. If other indexes take the same action, selling pressure could exceed $11 billion." He said: "Beyond the direct impact, this will also be a major blow to the 'institutional adoption' narrative that the entire model increasingly relies on."

What comes next?

In Thielen's view, the future requires a different type of Bitcoin-holding company: one that acts more like an asset manager rather than simply a company that keeps accumulating Bitcoin, because merely hoarding Bitcoin does not create value beyond the Bitcoin assets themselves. Thielen said: "To change this, Bitcoin treasury companies need to operate more like asset managers." He said: "They should fully utilize their asset base through yield strategies and prove to investors that they can outperform the market. That requires a different skill set from financial engineering." Olenik expressed a similar view but put it more bluntly. He called the index removal "long overdue." He said: "It is time to stop promoting the problem itself and instead promote the solution: Treasury 2.0." In other words, companies should stop simply hoarding Bitcoin and instead use those assets to create real value. Olenik noted: "This means evolving toward a Bitcoin-native operating model, acquiring Bitcoin for productive use, building Bitcoin infrastructure, driving network adoption and practical use of its monetary function, and through real business operations allocating, earning, and compounding sats (the smallest unit of Bitcoin) for shareholders, thereby standing at the forefront of the emerging agent era."

免责声明:投资有风险,本文并非投资建议,以上内容不应被视为任何金融产品的购买或出售要约、建议或邀请,作者或其他用户的任何相关讨论、评论或帖子也不应被视为此类内容。本文仅供一般参考,不考虑您的个人投资目标、财务状况或需求。TTM对信息的准确性和完整性不承担任何责任或保证,投资者应自行研究并在投资前寻求专业建议。

热议股票

  1. 1
     
     
     
     
  2. 2
     
     
     
     
  3. 3
     
     
     
     
  4. 4
     
     
     
     
  5. 5
     
     
     
     
  6. 6
     
     
     
     
  7. 7
     
     
     
     
  8. 8
     
     
     
     
  9. 9
     
     
     
     
  10. 10