Worthington Steel Inc. (WS) shares plummeted as much as 12.18% in pre-market trading on Thursday, erasing gains from the previous session, after the steel processor reported fiscal second-quarter revenue that fell short of analyst expectations, overshadowing an earnings beat.

For the quarter ended November 30, 2024, Worthington Steel reported adjusted earnings per diluted share of $0.19, up from $0.11 a year earlier and surpassing analyst estimates. However, net sales for the quarter declined to $739 million from $808 million in the same period last year, missing analysts' expectations of around $740.4 million.

The disappointing revenue numbers appeared to be the primary driver behind the steep sell-off in Worthington Steel's stock. The company cited lower volumes and prices as key factors impacting its top line, with direct tons sold falling 5% year-over-year and direct selling prices 4% lower than last year. CEO Geoff Gilmore also cited headwinds across several of the company's end markets as contributing to the weaker-than-expected revenue performance.