On Holding's premium playbook has long anchored its growth strategy: sell at full price and drive big margins rather than chase volume with discounted gear. Wall Street has generally cheered the idea, but investors sang a different tune Tuesday.
Shares of On Holding tumbled 8.1% to $34.49 Tuesday following its third-quarter earnings. The stock was on pace for its worst single-day percentage drop since Aug. 11, according to Dow Jones Market Data.
Investors were likely rattled by slowing growth in the Americas and softer-than-expected direct-to-consumer momentum.
While total sales of 931 million Swiss francs met Wall Street's estimates for the third quarter, the channel mix caught analysts off guard, William Blair analysts noted. Wholesale, which was projected to struggle given broad industry discounting, climbed 12%. Direct-to-consumer sales, however, grew 25%, missing analysts' consensus estimates of 33%.
William Blair has a Market Perform rating on On Holding stock.
Management previously noted that it's intentionally limiting wholesale inventory to protect its brand and curb price cuts -- a move rolled out in the fiscal second quarter that could dampen reported wholesale figures.
Sales growth in the Americas also has been a focal point for Wall Street.
The region, which drives more than half of total sales, has cooled from over 30% growth in the first quarter of 2025 down to the low-to-mid teens in 2026. In the third quarter, sales in the Americas grew by 12.4%. Cantor Fitzgerald analyst John Kernan attributed the pullback to the deliberate wholesale cleanup and intensifying competition from Nike and other footwear giants.
Under the hood of Tuesday's selloff, On Holding's profitability flexed strong muscle. The shoe maker's underlying gross margin reached 66.9% in the third quarter, which Truist Securities analysts said showcased high pricing power and resistance to heavy discounting in the broader market. The firm has a Buy rating and $40 price target on On Holding.
On Holding's full-price strategy was also what prompted Cantor Fitzgerald's Kernan to initiate coverage with an Overweight rating and a $46 price target.
While footwear generates nearly 90% of On Holding's total revenue, clothing has ramped up quickly. Kernan projects apparel sales to nearly triple from 255 million Swiss francs in 2026 to 712 million Swiss francs by 2029, eventually making up roughly 13% of total sales.
Aside from its pricing strategy, On Holding has expanded from running into mainstream sports like golf and soccer.
In September, it signed Real Madrid and French national team star Kylian Mbappé as a global ambassador.
On the production side, Kernan highlighted On's proprietary LightSpray automation tech, which aims to speed up the manufacturing process in the long haul.
For Truist Securities analysts, the stock drop Tuesday wasn't enough to shake their confidence in On Holding.
"We are optimistic about growth opportunities as they launch new innovations," the firm wrote.