Texas Data Center Approval Freeze Extended Again as Wall Street Warns US AI Infrastructure and Capex Momentum May Be Held Back

Deep News
11/06

After the US midterm elections, the main battleground for data center regulation is shifting from Washington to the states, and Texas's approval freeze may last until the middle of next year. Wall Street institutions are warning that the pace of US AI infrastructure buildout and capital expenditure could be dragged down as a result.

In the US midterm elections, the Democratic Party won majority seats in both the House and Senate and also won gubernatorial races in five states: Texas, Ohio, Nevada, Georgia and Michigan. Among them, Gina Hinojosa, a Democrat whose core platform centers on pausing new data center construction, became the first Democratic governor of Texas in more than three decades, a result that greatly surprised the market.

Goldman Sachs chief economist Jan Hatzius and his team noted in a latest report that new federal-level regulation would still need bipartisan support to pass the Senate and overcome a presidential veto, so the outlook for AI and data center regulation has not changed much. However, Democratic victories at the state level are likely to bring short-term data center bans. Goldman Sachs estimates that states where data center regulation could be further tightened after Democratic wins together account for about 45% of planned US data center capacity, with Texas alone accounting for about 26.7%. Goldman Sachs expects that the new governors of Texas, Georgia and Michigan may first introduce conditional bans while waiting for new legislation to be enacted. Jefferies analyst Julien Dumoulin-Smith pointed out that data centers have become a livelihood burden issue of shared concern to both parties, and he expects multiple state legislatures to continue pushing restrictive measures in 2027. In Virginia, known as the "data center corridor," a related moratorium bill has already begun advancing ahead of the state legislature's meeting on January 13 next year.

Texas data center approval freeze extended again

Even before the election, Texas Governor Greg Abbott had ordered a review in August of this year of all data centers waiting to connect to the grid, and in September he asked the state environmental regulator to suspend all data center permits. The market had originally expected that after his re-election, the freeze would gradually be lifted once the review ended. Wells Fargo analyst Jerry Revich pointed out that the election result turned this pause from "waiting for a review" into "waiting for legislation." The Texas state legislature will convene on January 12 next year, with the regular session ending on May 31. Semiconductor research firm SemiAnalysis estimates that if the freeze continues until the end of the session, that would be about eight months counting from September; if it needs to wait for new Texas rules to formally take effect, it could be close to a year.

According to a Jefferies review, Texas Governor-elect Hinojosa's main proposals include: pausing new data center permits and grid connection approvals until legislation is completed, with projects already under construction excluded; requiring large electricity users to bear the generation, transmission and interconnection costs they create; and gradually eliminating data center tax breaks, which she says cost the state government at least $1 billion each year. At the same time, the Texas lieutenant governor race also produced an upset. Democrat Vikki Goodwin defeated incumbent Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick by about 52% to 46%, and she also supports pausing new data center construction. Because the lieutenant governor controls the legislative agenda of the state Senate, this further increases the possibility that restrictive measures will be enacted. According to exit polls released by media on November 3 local time, 75% of surveyed Texas voters opposed building new data centers in their own communities.

How much does Texas matter?

Wells Fargo estimates that Texas has about 81 gigawatts of planned data center projects, accounting for about 20% of total planned capacity across the United States and more than twice that of Georgia or Virginia. Goldman Sachs, citing data from energy data platform Cleanview, calculates Texas's share at 26.7%. Note: Share of planned US data center capacity in states won by Democrats, with Texas at 26.7% under Goldman Sachs's calculation. SemiAnalysis expects that nearly 30% of new US data center capacity in 2028 will come from Texas, while current power equipment orders are mainly scheduled for delivery in that period. Once Texas projects are delayed, equipment manufacturers will come under direct pressure.

The scale directly affected is relatively small. Gordon Johnson, founder of independent US research firm GLJ Research, estimates that about 13 gigawatts of Texas data center capacity is "immediately exposed" to risk, enough to power about 10 million households. Johnson divides Texas data center projects into three categories: projects that already have power, permits and construction underway will continue; projects that have power but lack state environmental permits may be delayed by 12 to 18 months; projects lacking both may move to Louisiana or Oklahoma, or be shelved altogether. Chris Senyek, chief investment strategist at US sell-side research firm Wolfe Research, pointed out that Texas has about 1,000 announced data centers, nearly double Virginia's roughly 570. He believes Texas's approach is very likely to become a template for other states opposing data center expansion.

Equipment orders may be left in limbo

According to Wells Fargo analyst Revich, about 3 gigawatts of power generation equipment from Caterpillar and engine maker Cummins tied to Texas projects now appears to be stalled. Among them, the 2 gigawatts of Cummins orders tracked by Wells Fargo all come from a self-powered high-performance computing campus in West Texas; at least about 1.1 gigawatts of Caterpillar gas turbines, worth about $1.2 billion, involve projects such as Microsoft and Chevron's Project Kilby and the Stargate Abilene campus. Delivery times for power generation equipment are now booked out to 2030, and once campus construction is delayed, the corresponding delivery slots may be postponed or transferred to other customers. Because grid connection queues are long, "behind-the-meter" self-built power has become the main path for data centers to avoid grid bottlenecks, and Goldman Sachs expects this model to cover about 25% of data centers by 2030. However, self-built gas-fired generation facilities must obtain air emission permits, and the September ban also covers such permits, affecting related projects as well.

Capex concerns

Larry McDonald, founder of independent macro research platform The Bear Traps Report, citing data from Rice University's Baker Institute, said Texas data center investment reached $66 billion this year and has a baseline of $85 billion next year. Wells Fargo calculates that, all else equal, for every 10% reduction in Texas data center scale, US AI capital expenditure could fall by 1.6%. At Wells Fargo's data center conference, some attendees believed more than half of Texas projects could be canceled. Under that scenario, US AI capital expenditure could fall by about 8%. Note: US AI capital expenditure decline corresponding to different reduction levels in Texas data centers on the horizontal axis, with a halving potentially dragging it down by about 8% under Wells Fargo's calculation. McDonald pointed out that AI-related investment has contributed 1.2 percentage points to recent US GDP growth, and the five major hyperscale cloud providers spent $237 billion in a single quarter, up 99% year over year. With cloud providers' free cash flow already turning negative and about one-third of construction relying on debt, a slowdown in investment would directly drag on economic growth. McDonald also cited an estimate from energy research firm BNEF that each gigawatt of AI computing power generates about $1.76 billion in revenue per month. Based on that calculation, if all of the 13 gigawatts of capacity estimated by Johnson were delayed by 12 to 18 months, about $275 billion to $410 billion in revenue would theoretically be pushed back.

"Demand delayed, not disappearing"

Wall Street has differing views on how long the ban will last. Goldman Sachs chief economist Hatzius believes data centers are not the issue voters care about most, and even if related bans are introduced, they will not last too long. Goldman Sachs utilities analyst Carly Davenport also pointed out that what is mainly affected in Texas is development timing, not the long-term opportunity. Jefferies's judgment is "demand delayed, not disappearing." The firm said some new governors in certain states are pragmatic and could introduce relevant arrangements as early as the first quarter of next year. Wells Fargo noted that the next key observation point is the review report that Texas grid operator ERCOT will submit on December 10. The report stems from Abbott's August directive requiring a review of all data center projects waiting to connect to the grid, and it will be the first time outsiders obtain an official-level review conclusion. However, the report itself will not restart approvals, and when the freeze is lifted will still depend on legislative progress in next year's state legislature.

免責聲明:投資有風險,本文並非投資建議,以上內容不應被視為任何金融產品的購買或出售要約、建議或邀請,作者或其他用戶的任何相關討論、評論或帖子也不應被視為此類內容。本文僅供一般參考,不考慮您的個人投資目標、財務狀況或需求。TTM對信息的準確性和完整性不承擔任何責任或保證,投資者應自行研究並在投資前尋求專業建議。

熱議股票

  1. 1
     
     
     
     
  2. 2
     
     
     
     
  3. 3
     
     
     
     
  4. 4
     
     
     
     
  5. 5
     
     
     
     
  6. 6
     
     
     
     
  7. 7
     
     
     
     
  8. 8
     
     
     
     
  9. 9
     
     
     
     
  10. 10