Elevance Health sued autism-therapy provider the Perfect Child, alleging that it paid the company $160 million due to misleading claims over the last five years.
The lawsuit, filed in New York state court on Wednesday, cites a Wall Street Journal article that detailed the Perfect Child's practices of charging insurers rates that could exceed $30,000 a day and attempting to collect directly from families when they balked at the bills, despite promises they would face little or no out-of-pocket costs.
The lawsuit, which reveals for the first time the amount of money the company's tactics extracted from a single insurer, adds pressure from private insurers to the growing government scrutiny on the Perfect Child. On Tuesday, the Journal reported that the Federal Bureau of Investigation was investigating the Brooklyn, N.Y.-based autism-therapy company.
Elevance's lawsuit alleged the Perfect Child's conduct amounted to fraud, breach of contract, conspiracy and other claims. Elevance operates private health plans under the Anthem brand in many states, including ones it administers on behalf of employers.
Alan Schabes, a Cleveland lawyer who said Thursday he represents the Perfect Child, said he was still reviewing the lawsuit. Perfect Child founder Simcha Bendet, didn't respond to requests for comment. An Elevance spokeswoman declined to comment.
The Elevance lawsuit said the Perfect Child had a contract with its insurance units until June of this year that required it to accept in-network payment rates when treating its members.
Instead, Elevance alleged, the company billed the insurer through a web of more than 100 limited-liability companies that weren't in its network and billed far higher out-of-network rates.
In one example, the out-of-network subsidiaries charged an average of about $1,700 an hour for assessments conducted by autism-therapy workers, even though the Perfect Child's contracted rate was a little over $400 an hour, the court filings say.
The Journal reviewed invoices and insurance records showing the Perfect Child's affiliates at times billed insurers, including Elevance units, and patients more than $30,000 for a single day of service. Records show the Perfect Child also billed other insurers including Aetna, units of UnitedHealth Group and Cigna Group though its web of LLCs.
There is no law limiting what out-of-network providers can charge, but Elevance's suit claims misrepresentations by the company to the insurer and its members triggered excessive payments.
In all, the Perfect Child's affiliated companies billed Elevance for $800 million from 2021 through March 2026, the lawsuit says. Elevance says it denied many of those claims, including $102 million in charges it said were duplicate bills. But, it says it wound up paying out $160 million.
In addition to its out-of-network billing tactics, Elevance says the Perfect Child billed for impossible amounts of services, including 2,000 times when it claimed to provide therapy to a single patient for more than 12 hours in a day.