Texas Has Turned into a Wasteland for House Flippers

Dow Jones
11/20

Javier Maldonado has been flipping homes in San Antonio for seven years, for a total of about 30 homes, and he's got a formula that he said has helped him consistently make a profit -- or at least not lose money.

"I don't recall ever being negative" on a sale, he said. "But I've broken even on some properties."

Nevertheless, in the past year, the math of flipping in San Antonio has gotten much tougher, even for an experienced flipper like Maldonado. The combination of rising mortgage rates, skyrocketing property taxes and oversupply from a residential-construction boom during Covid has made it the country's least-profitable major metro for home flipping.

In the second quarter, the median profit margin on a home or condo flip in San Antonio was a loss of 0.3%, according to a recent report from property data firm ATTOM. Nationwide, median profitability of a single-family home or condo flip was 21.6%, the lowest it's been since the 2007-2008 housing crash. Despite the doom and gloom, flipping profits remained strong in some cities, notably Pittsburgh, Buffalo, N.Y., New Orleans, Virginia Beach, Va., and Philadelphia, the five major metros with the highest profit margins.

Maldonado said despite the challenges in San Antonio, he's sticking to his flipping formula: He buys homes with an After Repair Value, or ARV, of $250,000 to $350,000, which he said is the sweet spot for sales in the areas where he operates, and aims to make at least $30,000 in profit on each sale. However, "it's gotten much harder to hit my targets," he said.

For flippers in San Antonio and the four other least-profitable metros -- Dallas, Austin, Houston and Salt Lake City -- the news is even worse. The study calculated profit margins using only the difference between the flipper's purchase price and the flipper's eventual sale price. The profitability analysis didn't take into account the cost to rehab a home or the carrying costs, such as insurance, taxes, mortgage payments, utilities and concessions. All in, the report said, these costs could end up being between 20% and 33% of the ARV, based on estimates from flipping veterans. The study also didn't include any flips that took longer than 12 months to sell. That means for a "median" rehabbed flip in these cities, losses are guaranteed.

Fortunately for Maldonado and other flippers in these cities, national and aggregated housing data don't capture the micro-markets and street-level dynamics that house flippers depend on to turn a profit: the home that has fallen into disrepair in a high-value neighborhood, the widower needing to sell fast, or the owner facing foreclosure who will part with a house in exchange for a buyer simply taking over the mortgage.

Danny Johnson, who has lived in San Antonio since he was 2, has been flipping homes there since 2000. He was doing about 20 a year when the housing crisis hit and "we had to find a way to work through it," he said. He and his then-partner (now his ex-wife) started doing owner financing for their buyers. It helped keep deals flowing despite much stricter underwriting rules from traditional banks.

Today, though, creative financing won't help.

To weather the current climate, Johnson is doing fewer flips -- he said he's comfortable doing 10 to 15 this year compared with 20 last year -- and he buys older homes, often 20 to 40 years old. He's trying to stay away from homes with bad underpinnings, but that's tough in San Antonio, where the soil ruins foundations. He's also doing full remodels on his flips, not just replacing some features and leaving others. What's selling fast are homes with new interiors, especially kitchens and bathrooms, he said. Piecemeal renovations won't sell as fast, and fast is the key to profit.

"I like it because I know what I'm going to have to do and I budget for it," he said. "It also saves the hassle of thinking, 'Oh, those cabinets are sort of nice.' Now it doesn't matter. We know they're all coming out." He aims for homes with an ARV of $250,000 to $350,000, he tries to keep a 20% profit margin, and he aims to sell within 30 to 60 days.

Location is also crucial, he said. He's now avoiding buying around two reservoirs, Canyon Lake and Lake Medina, that have pricey homes, but that were nearly empty because of historic yearslong drought. This summer, heavy rains mostly refilled them and owners rushed to put their homes on the market. Unfortunately, he had already bought a home to flip near Canyon Lake, and it languished on the market longer than he likes, although it recently went under contract after being listed for $390,000.

He's also avoiding suburban areas like New Braunfels and "far west" San Antonio, where builders of many new-construction homes are now slashing prices and offering seller financing at low rates as well as other buyer concessions. Instead, he's focusing his efforts closer to downtown San Antonio, where there is less competition from those builders. His flips in that area, he said, are getting multiple offers.

Local real-estate agent Kristen Smith, of Serhant, said while there are some one-off new builds closer to the center of the city, they aren't new-build neighborhoods like you see further out. "Anything inside the 1604 loop," she said of the highway that rings the city's downtown, "there is going to be far less competition from new builds." But elsewhere, the competition flippers face from new builds is fierce: According to data she cited from MLS, 25% of sales in San Antonio in 2021 were new builds. Today, it's 40%.

There are some very bright spots in the flipping landscape. One is the Pittsburgh greater metropolitan area, which showed a median profitability for the second quarter of 81.5%, the highest among metros with populations over 1 million. The Pittsburgh area's flipping superpower, according to local real-estate agent Tarasa Hurley of River Point Realty is a combination of factors including lower housing costs (a median sales price of $234,000 as of Sept. 30, compared with $366,000 nationwide, according to Zillow). The area also has a stable, diversified job market that brings a constant influx of new home buyers, older but well-built housing stock, and a skilled trade workforce that can afford to live in the area, which brings renovation costs down. "Our ability to find people who can do the work is a big reason why flippers are in good shape here," said Hurley.

Maireny Diaz is a school paraprofessional who lives and works in New York City's the Bronx, but who has started flipping homes in the Pittsburgh area. She and her husband, Jhony Rosado, who drives a limousine, started flipping in the city after he had a client from Pittsburgh who told them flippers there were getting good returns. After doing some research, they bought a home for $51,000, put about $50,000 into rehabbing it, and sold it "really fast" for $130,000, Diaz said. "It was a good profit and it was a great experience."

They bought their second flip in New Kensington, about 18 miles from downtown Pittsburgh, in early October for $50,000. They plan to spend $50,000 on the rehab and target a sale price of $150,000 to $175,000. They financed both of their flips using fix-and-flip loans, financing from a hard money lender that generally offers six-month interest-only terms. With $2,000 down, they pay $1,150 a month to service the debt on the New Kensington home.

The clock is ticking. If Diaz and Rosado don't sell by the end of the end of the six month interest-only term, financing costs will dig way into their profit. Diaz is optimistic they can pull it off after their successful first flip. But just in case, they have a Plan B. If the home takes more than two months to sell, "we would rent out the property and refinance it if the numbers make sense," she said. "This way, we can potentially generate rental income, recover some of our investment, and turn the property into a long-term asset."

 

應版權方要求,你需要登入查看該內容

免責聲明:投資有風險,本文並非投資建議,以上內容不應被視為任何金融產品的購買或出售要約、建議或邀請,作者或其他用戶的任何相關討論、評論或帖子也不應被視為此類內容。本文僅供一般參考,不考慮您的個人投資目標、財務狀況或需求。TTM對信息的準確性和完整性不承擔任何責任或保證,投資者應自行研究並在投資前尋求專業建議。

熱議股票

  1. 1
     
     
     
     
  2. 2
     
     
     
     
  3. 3
     
     
     
     
  4. 4
     
     
     
     
  5. 5
     
     
     
     
  6. 6
     
     
     
     
  7. 7
     
     
     
     
  8. 8
     
     
     
     
  9. 9
     
     
     
     
  10. 10