On November 19, Li Xunlei, Chief Economist of Zhongtai International, spoke at an offline event, exploring the impact of the AI era on industry and society from the perspectives of AI development, economic divergence trends, population mobility, and urbanization progress, as well as real estate cycles and housing price trends in core cities.
Li Xunlei has conducted extensive and long-term research in macroeconomic fields such as population mobility and urbanization. He predicted in 2017 that China's real estate would peak around 2020, a judgment that was highly controversial at a time when the property market was broadly bullish, but subsequent real estate trends have validated this prediction over time.
At this event, Li Xunlei pointed out that from the perspective of the global economic cycle, we are experiencing an AI era. AI penetration rates will continue to rise, and our development is much faster than during the internet era, with massive capital expenditure driving economic growth.
For China, this year's export growth, in US dollar terms, should exceed 20%. Of this, 5% comes from chip exports. These changes are just beginning, but there will be more and more going forward. Our current token usage has reached 140 trillion, representing more than a thousandfold increase over two years. The new economy represented by AI will exert an increasingly strong and growing pull on China's economy.
The 15th Five-Year Plan proposes that by 2030, AI output value should reach over 10 trillion yuan. According to data, in 2025, China's core AI industry scale will exceed 1.2 trillion yuan, indicating enormous room for growth.
Meanwhile, China's overall urbanization process is slowing, but population is flowing toward large cities, and large-city urbanization is in full swing. After China's population peaked in 2021, the country's population has been declining every year. However, on one hand, we must recognize the overall trend of population decline; on the other hand, we must see that populations in third-, fourth-, and fifth-tier cities are shrinking, while first- and second-tier cities, provincial capitals, and new first-tier cities are all experiencing net population inflows.
Li Xunlei believes that because we strictly limit population inflows to mega-cities, Shanghai's current population inflow is slower than expected, so he remains optimistic about Shanghai's future and Shanghai's real estate.
From the perspective of personal income tax, high-end talent is flowing to large cities. The combined personal income tax revenue of 8 cities already accounts for more than half of the national total.
At the same time, he stated that divergence is the dominant trend. Industries are diverging, and profit concentration is increasing. In the first half of this year, the profits of China's top ten companies accounted for one-third of the profits of China's 5,550 listed companies; the top 1% of listed companies — just over 50 companies — accounted for two-thirds of all A-share listed company profits.
We now face the pressure of economic transformation and are witnessing weak consumption. These factors are actually forcing us to adopt economies of scale and agglomeration effects.
The Global Economy Enters the AI Era, AI Penetration Will Keep Rising
From the perspective of the global economic cycle, I believe we are experiencing an AI era. The beginning of this era, I think, is still at a relatively early stage, and it will have a tremendous impact on our urban layout, population concentration, and the development of emerging industries.
AI penetration will continue to rise. Already, some tasks have been replaced, such as programming. Our development is much faster than during the internet era, with massive capital expenditure driving economic growth.
This year, AI's contribution to US GDP growth is nearly 1 percentage point, accounting for roughly one-third of US GDP growth. In Taiwan across the strait, nominal GDP growth in the first three quarters of this year reached 20%. It's hard to imagine — 10 years ago when I visited Taipei, financial professionals there complained to me that Taiwan's GDP that year was negative. Ten years later, it's over 20% nominal GDP growth, all brought by AI, because Taiwan's electronics industry is relatively advanced.
For China, without AI this year, our export growth would not have been so fast. This year's export growth in US dollar terms should exceed 20%. Of this, 5% comes from chip exports. These changes are just beginning but will become more numerous going forward.
For example, our token usage has already reached 140 trillion, a more than thousandfold increase over two years. Where is the massive growth in token usage mainly applied? Incomplete statistics show it's used in short drama production. That's why Hongguo has risen — our entertainment industry is the first to apply AI, bringing enormous changes.
I believe the future prospects are very broad; the impact of AI on China's economy still needs to be fully estimated.
AI Output Value to Reach Over 10 Trillion Yuan During the 15th Five-Year Plan
Although we face downward pressure from the traditional economy, the new economy represented by AI will exert an increasingly strong and growing pull on China's economy.
The 15th Five-Year Plan outline proposes that AI output value should reach over 10 trillion yuan during the entire 15th Five-Year Plan period. In this way, the proportion of our traditional growth drivers will decline, and the proportion of new growth drivers will rise.
For Shanghai, this is also a huge boost. Because Shanghai is required to be built into a global science and technology innovation center, AI applications will be implemented in many fields in Shanghai. With the surge in inference computing power, computing-power synergy is China's advantage. In the future, the robotics industry in Shanghai should also be a national leader, and its pulling effect on various aspects will be very significant.
Urbanization Is Slowing, Population Flows to Large Cities
Related to this, it's not hard to see that China's overall urbanization process is slowing. But as early as 20 years ago, I consistently emphasized a viewpoint: China's large-city urbanization process will accelerate. The essence of urbanization is actually large-city urbanization — population concentrating in large cities.
What we now see is that China's urbanization process is slowing, but where is the population flowing? To large cities. Large-city urbanization is in full swing.
Shanghai is now a city with net population inflow. In the past, China's population flow was very simple — from rural areas to cities. In 2010, the number of migrant workers entering cities was 12 million per year; now it's only 1 million per year. The population of large cities mainly comes from small and medium-sized cities flowing to large cities.
Shanghai's Population Inflow Is Slower Than Expected; Optimistic on Shanghai Real Estate
So why am I bullish on Shanghai? Why bullish on the Yangtze River Delta and Pearl River Delta? Because the nation's population mainly flows to these regions.
In the past, population flowed from rural areas to small and medium-sized cities. Now two-thirds of cities are experiencing net population outflow, while also facing the pressure of China's total population decline. After China's population peaked in 2021, the population has been declining every year.
However, on one hand, we must see the overall trend of population decline; on the other hand, we must see that populations in third-, fourth-, and fifth-tier cities are shrinking, while first- and second-tier cities, provincial capitals, and new first-tier cities are all experiencing net population inflows.
These are some statistics I compiled. You'll find that, apart from Beijing, the populations of Shanghai, Shenzhen, and Chongqing — these four municipalities — are all experiencing net inflows.
Because we strictly limit population inflows to mega-cities, Shanghai's population inflow is slower than expected. Therefore, I remain optimistic about Shanghai's future and Shanghai's real estate.
The More Developed the Economy, the Higher the Population Concentration
This chart actually reflects what I said earlier. On the right is the United States. Where is US GDP generated? In these scattered dots. In the future, its concentration will only increase. These scattered dots account for half of the nation's GDP.
According to World Bank statistics, 1.5% of the world's land area creates more than half of global GDP. So the more developed the economy, the higher its concentration, and the higher the population concentration.
The reason cities are attractive is not just employment opportunities — they have comprehensive advantages in culture, education, healthcare, and more. That is a city's charm; it's not simply formed for making a living.
From a Personal Income Tax Perspective, High-End Talent Flows to Large Cities
This chart reflects that our personal income tax concentration is increasing. What does that indicate? That high-end talent is flowing to large cities. From a purely tax perspective, you can see which cities have a better future.
Eight cities were surveyed. What's interesting? Shanghai is No. 1 — no suspense. Beijing No. 2 — no suspense. Shenzhen No. 3 — no suspense. Guangzhou barely holds No. 4, very close to Hangzhou. Hangzhou is No. 5, Ningbo No. 6. These two Zhejiang cities crushed Jiangsu's Suzhou and Nanjing.
Looking at where high-end talent in these cities flows could bring opportunities for our industrial development and real estate development.
Regardless, the combined personal income tax revenue of these 8 cities already accounts for more than half of the national total, and this proportion will likely continue to rise.
Divergence Is the Dominant Trend: Industry Divergence, Company Divergence
So my view is that divergence is the dominant trend. From listed company performance, it's completely evident — industry divergence, and increasing profit concentration.
We often say the US has severe divergence. The profits of the US AI Big Seven account for one-third of S&P 500 company profits, and their market value accounts for 37%.
Turning back to China, the profits of China's top ten companies in the first half of this year account for one-third of China's 5,550 listed companies. So the divergence we see is reflected in every aspect. First, industry divergence; second, company divergence.
The top 1% of Chinese listed companies — just over 50 companies — account for two-thirds of all A-share listed company profits. Divergence is inevitable.
No Country Develops in a Balanced Way; This Forces Us to Adopt Economies of Scale
We now face the pressure of economic transformation and are witnessing weak consumption. These factors are actually forcing economic transformation, forcing us to adopt economies of scale and agglomeration effects.
The world's development has never been balanced. Of course, we dream of balanced development, but if you examine any developed country globally, none has achieved balanced development — the result is always unbalanced development.
This year's pressure comes from declining investment growth and declining fiscal expenditure — this has never happened in history. Now, not only is investment negative, but all three investment entities — manufacturing, infrastructure, and real estate — are negative. This has never been encountered before. This further requires us to think about where to invest, to choose more reasonable and more future-oriented investment approaches.
After the Real Estate Downturn, Divergence Will Occur; Core Area Prices Will Remain Firm
Moderator: I'd like to ask Mr. Li, what kind of real estate assets can be considered assets that participate in the cycle?
Li Xunlei: First, if we look at history over the long term, cycles are inevitable. Some people question: would first-tier city housing prices also fall? I say if they fall, they'll all fall together. Whether first-tier or second-tier, real estate has a downward cycle, but after the decline, divergence will certainly occur. This divergence is closely related to population, economic transformation, and industrial development.
US housing prices also fall, European housing prices also fall — all inevitable. But after the decline, you'll see that prices in New York remain firm, and prices in core areas of London and Paris remain firm. That's the result of divergence.
I often give an example: how is the area of a circle calculated? Pi R squared. If the distance from the core point is halved, the area decreases by three-quarters. That is, the more core the location, the scarcer the area.
Of course, I haven't done much research on regional value. I'm just speaking from the basic logic of economics. I think these locations' future — as I mentioned earlier — can reference cases like the Seine River and the Thames River.