Goldman Sachs and Citi hold divergent views on the French government bond outlook, with differing opinions on how much the market has already priced in potential new election risks.
Goldman Sachs strategists, including Simon Freycenet, indicated that current pricing has "largely absorbed" near-term election risks following Monday's unexpected prime ministerial resignation that triggered a bond selloff. This pushed the risk premium of French 10-year government bonds relative to German bonds to its highest level this year.
Citi takes a more cautious stance, warning that bond spreads are "just beginning" to reflect election risks. Strategist Aman Bansal believes current levels only reflect approximately 14 basis points of political risk premium, below the 20 basis points touched in August - a premium that could expand further if early elections materialize.
These differing perspectives highlight the increasingly severe challenges facing the French bond market, following the forced resignation of Sebastian Le Cornu due to difficulties in drafting a budget proposal that could appease opposition parties. He became France's fifth prime minister in two years.
French President Macron has requested Le Cornu to negotiate with various parties by Wednesday evening, representing a final effort to prevent further deterioration of the crisis. While it remains unclear how to respond if negotiations fail, one option Macron might consider is declaring new parliamentary elections.
Goldman Sachs maintains its year-end target of 70 basis points for the France-Germany 10-year government bond yield spread, "despite upside risks." Given the current spread of approximately 86 basis points, this suggests a recovery in the bond market over the coming months. Freycenet noted that this forecast would face challenges if economic growth significantly deteriorates or fiscal prospects worsen.